Buying a car—new or used—is a major investment. But what happens when your vehicle keeps breaking down despite repeated repairs? If you’re dealing with constant mechanical problems, there’s a chance you’ve unknowingly purchased a lemon. Fortunately, California has one of the strongest lemon laws in the U.S. to protect consumers in this situation.
So, how can you tell if your car qualifies as a lemon under California law? Here’s a detailed breakdown to help you determine whether your vehicle fits the criteria—and what you can do if it does.
What Is a Lemon?
A “lemon” is a vehicle with a substantial defect affecting its use, safety, or value and cannot be fixed after a reasonable number of repair attempts while still under the manufacturer’s warranty.
California’s Lemon Law applies to:
New vehicles
Used vehicles (still under manufacturer’s warranty)
Leased vehicles
Certified pre-owned cars
Electric vehicles
Commercial vehicles under 10,000 pounds (if the business owns fewer than five vehicles)
Signs That Your Car Might Be a Lemon
Wondering whether your situation qualifies under the California lemon law? Here are some telltale signs that your car may legally be considered a lemon:
1. Frequent Repairs for the Same Problem
If you’ve taken your car to the dealership multiple times for the same issue, and it’s still unresolved, that’s a red flag. The law typically requires:
At least two attempts to fix a serious safety defect (like brake failure or steering issues)
Four or more attempts for less serious but repeated defects
Or the car has been out of service for 30 or more total days due to repairs
These standards apply while the vehicle is under the original manufacturer’s warranty.
2. The Problem Affects Safety, Use, or Value
Not all defects qualify. Minor issues like a broken radio or cosmetic scratches usually don’t meet the Lemon law standard. But problems like:
Engine failure
Transmission issues
Faulty airbags
Power steering malfunctions
Persistent electrical faults
These can seriously impact your car’s safety and usability, making them more likely to qualify.
3. The Car Is Still Under Warranty
California’s lemon law doesn’t apply to issues that happen after the warranty has expired. That’s why it’s important to act early. If your vehicle is still under the original factory or powertrain warranty, and you’re already seeing issues, start documenting everything.
Keep Good Records
You’ll need proof of the issue and the repair history to support your case. Make sure to collect:
All repair orders and invoices
Descriptions of the problem from service advisors
Dates and mileage of each visit
Towing or rental car receipts
Warranty information
Clear documentation is essential if you file a lemon law claim in Anaheim, CA, or anywhere else in the state.
What Happens If Your Car Qualifies?
If your vehicle meets the lemon criteria, California law gives you the right to request relief from the manufacturer. You could be entitled to:
A full refund (minus a small usage deduction)
A replacement vehicle
Cash compensation if you choose to keep the car
Reimbursement for rental cars, towing, and legal fees
In some cases, if the manufacturer is found to have acted in bad faith—like denying your claim without reason—you may also be awarded civil penalties up to twice the value of your damages.
What If the Dealership Blames You?
Manufacturers and dealerships sometimes argue that the defect was caused by misuse, lack of maintenance, or an accident. This is why it’s so important to:
Follow the recommended service schedule
Only take your car to authorized service centers while under warranty
Keep all your service and communication records
When Should You File a Lemon Law Claim?
Timing matters. In California, you generally have to take legal action four years from when you first noticed the issue. But waiting too long can make your case harder to prove. If you’re located in Orange County and dealing with a defective vehicle, don’t hesitate to file a lemon law claim in Anaheim, CA, before your warranty or deadline passes.
Do You Need a Lawyer?
You’re not required to hire a lawyer—but it’s highly recommended. Lemon law attorneys know how to deal with car manufacturers, who often try to settle for less than you deserve. And under California law, the manufacturer pays your legal fees if you win.
With legal support, you’ll have a better chance of:
Proving your case
Getting a faster resolution
Receiving full compensation
Avoiding unnecessary stress
Final Thoughts
If your vehicle feels more like a problem than a solution, it’s worth asking: Could it be a lemon? California’s lemon law is designed to protect buyers just like you from ongoing repair nightmares and unsafe driving conditions.
Look at your repair history, gather your paperwork, and contact a qualified lemon law attorney if things don’t feel right. Whether you file a lemon law claim in Anaheim, CA, or elsewhere in the state, knowing your rights is the first step toward getting the relief you deserve.
The post Understanding California’s Lemon Law: Know Your Rights appeared first on Moss and Fog.